Evaluating LLM outputs reliably

By Ryze AI Team

If you cannot measure it, you cannot improve it. Traditional software has unit tests; LLM applications need evals. Without them you are tuning prompts by feel and shipping regressions you will not notice until a user complains.

Build an eval set

Collect 30 to 100 real inputs with expected outputs or grading rubrics. Source them from actual user queries, support tickets, and edge cases you have seen, not from your imagination. Include easy cases to confirm baseline competence, hard cases that stress the model, and adversarial cases that try to break it. Store the set in version control alongside your code so it evolves with the product.

Expected outputs do not have to be exact strings. For classification, the label suffices. For open-ended answers, a rubric describing what a good answer contains is more useful than a single reference string, because there are many acceptable phrasings.

Metrics

Use exact match for structured output such as JSON fields or labels. For free text, exact match is too strict; prefer semantic similarity, rubric-based scoring, or LLM-as-judge. Always track latency and cost as first-class metrics alongside quality, because a model that scores 95 percent but takes eight seconds and costs ten cents per call is not production-ready. Report percentiles, not averages, since tail latency is what users feel.

LLM as judge

Use a stronger model to score outputs against a rubric. It scales to hundreds of cases and catches nuances that string matching misses. Calibrate it against human labels on a subset of 20 to 30 cases before trusting it; if the judge disagrees with humans often, fix the rubric or the judge prompt. Watch for position bias, verbosity bias, and self-preference bias, where a model favors its own style. Mitigate by randomizing option order and using a different model family as judge.

Regression testing

Run evals on every prompt or model change, ideally in CI. Track scores over time and plot them. A two-point drop is a signal once your eval set is stable, not noise. Set a threshold below which a change is blocked from merging. Keep the eval fast enough to run on every commit; if it takes an hour, people will skip it.

Edge cases and red-teaming

Add failures to the eval set as they occur in production so they are not repeated. Include empty input, very long input, non-English text, injection attempts, and out-of-domain questions. Red-team deliberately: try to make the model leak data, ignore instructions, or produce harmful content. The goal is not a perfect score but a documented understanding of where the system breaks and how badly.

Resources: DeepEval, Ragas, and promptfoo.